Statistical Process Control

Additional Topic
Math 219

Martin

What is statistical process control (SPC)?

  • A tool that uses statistical methods to monitor a process to improve quality and consistency1

    • Using quantitative techniques to interpret data
    • Applied to a process involving people, equipment, materials, and environment working together to produce an identifiable, measurable output
    • That behaves in a predictable, consistent manner
  • It is also referred to as statistical quality control

  • Unlike other topics in this course it is not considered an inference test

  • However, SPC determines if variability is consistent with the process

    • The normal variability in a process is referred to as “common cause” variability and any other source of variability is referred to as “special cause”
    • Common cause is due to random variation in the process, like the \(null\) hypothesis in statistical inference
    • Special cause is due to variation caused by something other than the process, like the \(alternative\) hypothesis

Applications of SPC

  • SPC was first developed for the manufacturing industry to reduce defective or non-conforming products

  • Today it is used in many different applications for example

    • To improve quality and consistency the practice in healthcare1
    • In service industry to improve customer satisfaction 2

Data for SPC

  • To control a process data is collected from process samples

  • Both categorical and quantitative variables are used

    • Numerical variables are called variable characteristics
    • Categorical variables are attribute characteristics
  • Fixing the number of samples collected is important in SPC

    • Too many samples can cost time and resources
    • Too few samples gives too much variability in control data

Determining the state of a process

  • If process variation is from common cause
    • The process is considered in-control
  • But if process variation is due to special cause
    • The process is considered out-of-control
  • To determine the state of a process
    • We typically use a control chart

Control chart for attribute characteristics

  • This control chart is called a p-chart because it is
    • Based on the proportion of non-conforming parts

p-chart for silicon chip defects

  • The middle line on the chart is
    • the long-run or population proportion
    • p for the process when it is in control
  • The upper control line (UCL) and lower control line (LCL)
    • Are 3 standard deviations (SD) above p
    • And 3SD below p1

Probability process is in- or out-of-control

  • The risk of getting an out-of-control response
    • From an in-control process is very small
  • Our model for a proportion is the normal distribution
    • The probability of getting a sample 3SD above or below the mean
    • From common cause (random chance) is 0.0027 or 0.27%
  • So, 99.7% of the time an in-control process should give
    • An in-control response or sample

Attribute characteristics control chart data

  • We can view the data for the attribute characteristics
    • As a histogram and evaluate normality assumption

histogram of defects

Variable characteristics data

  • This example shows the size of aerosol particles
    • View the data before creating a control chart
    • We can see that the variability isn’t random

Chart for aerosol particle size

Variable characteristics control chart data

  • We can view the data for the variable characteristics
    • As a histogram and evaluate normality assumption like before

histogram of particle size

Variable characteristics (Shewhart) control chart

  • With control levels based on the subset
    • You can see that most of the samples are out-of-control
    • Indicating special-cause variation

Shewhart control chart

  • The middle line on the chart is
    • the long-run or population mean
    • x-bar for the process when it is in control
  • The upper control line (UCL) and lower control line (LCL)
    • Are 3 standard deviations (SD) above x-bar
    • And 3SD below x-bar

Additional rules for out-of-control process

  • These are the “Western Electric Company (WECO)” rules
    • For identifying out-of-control samples
    • In addition to being 3SD above the mean or
    • 3SD below the mean
    • 8 consecutive points above or below mean
    • 4 out of 5 points 1SD above or 1SD below the mean
    • 2 out of 3 points 2SD above or 2SD below the mean
  • These added rules increase Type I errors by 3X over 3SD rule alone

Identifying source of the special cause variability

  • Once special cause variability is found
    • The source of the variability needs to be identified
  • There are several tools for this part of SPC1
    • Pareto chart
    • Cause-and-effect (fishbone) diagram
    • Flowchart
    • And many others

Pareto Chart

Example Pareto chart on complaints

Cause-and-effect (fishbone) diagram

  • Example fishbone diagram

Fishbone diagram for part size error

Flowchart diagram

Flowchart diagram for customer comment